ServiceNow Consulting Services for Mid-Sized Enterprises: The Evaluation Criteria That Actually Matter
A CIO of a 1,200-person insurance broker sent me his RFP last week. Twenty-eight pages. Seventeen scoring dimensions. A weighted matrix that would not have looked out of place at a defence procurement office. He wanted an outside opinion before he sent it out to five shortlisted partners. I read it on the train home from Vienna and called him the next morning. I told him the RFP was excellent, thorough, and would almost certainly help him pick the wrong partner. He was quiet for a moment and then asked what I meant. What I meant is that the RFP was optimised for the wrong buyer. It was a scale-down of the RFP a Fortune 100 uses to buy from a Big 4. It scored partners on things that matter when you are running a hundred-million-euro programme with three parallel workstreams and a dedicated PMO. It scored almost none of the things that determine whether a mid-market ServiceNow implementation actually ships on time and gets adopted after go-live. If you sit in the 300 to 3,000 employee band and you are about to send a ServiceNow RFP into the market, the evaluation criteria you use to sort responses will decide the next two years of your platform's life. This is not the same...